CUSTOMS SMUGGLING AND VAT: CONSTITUTIONAL COURT CHANGES COURSE ON ASSET FORFEITURE
Data: 09 July 2025
Categorie: Customs, International Taxation, Tax-Duty Litigation
Autore: Vanessa Antonelli
Ruling No. 93/2025: Mandatory forfeiture is unlawful if tax debt has been paid in full
The Constitutional Court, in its ruling No. 93 of July 3, 2025 , decisively intervenes in the matter of VAT smuggling, declaring the constitutional illegitimacy of the compulsory confiscation of imported goods when the offender has made full payment of the evaded tax, accessories and fines.
The regulation of customs smuggling has always been characterized by high severity. In particular, Article 70(1) of Presidential Decree No. 633/1972, in recalling en bloc the customs provisions on border duties, mandated the compulsory confiscation of infringing goods, even in cases where the offender had then fully remedied the VAT debt on importation.
An approach that the Constitutional Court has deemed disproportionate and unreasonable, violating the principles of equality (Art. 3 Const.) and proportionality of criminal and administrative sanctions. All the more so considering that for domestic VAT, Art. 12-bis of Legislative Decree 74/2000 already excludes confiscation if the tax is paid.
The Court’s decision: priority to the restorative function of the tribute
In the explanatory statement, the Constitutional Court makes it clear that once the state has recovered its tax claim (tax, interest and penalty), the guarantee function that justifies the compulsory confiscation of assets is also lost. Maintaining the ablative measure would thus result in a disproportionate sanction that lacks a deterrent function.
Accordingly, the Court declares Article 70 unconstitutional insofar as it does not exclude the mandatory confiscation of property in cases of full payment by the infringer.
However, the pronouncement leaves out of the picture the legally thorny issue of administrative contraband, that is, contraband sanctioned only administratively and not criminally, which today suffers analogical applications of Article 301 TULD that are difficult to reconcile with the principle of legality enshrined in Article 25 Const.
It now remains to be seen how the Customs Agency will adjust its operational practices, which until now have applied mandatory forfeiture automatically even when there are subsequent payments by taxpayers.
Import VAT and customs duties: a substantive difference, not just a formal one
The Constitutional Court, in this ruling, clearly reiterates a fundamental but often overlooked principle in customs practice: import VAT is not a border duty, either by nature or by purpose.
The historical confusion between VAT and duties stems from the fact that both taxes are cleared and collected at customs, but this operational coincidence cannot obscure the profound structural and functional differences between the two institutions:
- Customs duties constitute real border taxes, designed to protect the domestic market, governed by autonomous EU rules, with both a fiscal and regulatory function in foreign trade.
- Import VAT, on the other hand, is a component of the domestic VAT system, designed to ensure tax neutrality between domestic and imported goods. It is not a customs levy as such, but the natural complement to the VAT system for domestic and EU consumption purposes.
The practical implications for businesses and professionals
For companies engaged in international trade, the ruling opens up the possibility of avoiding customs confiscation in the case of timely remedied VAT violations. However, it will be crucial to monitor the upcoming guidelines of the agency and the courts of merit to see how and when this important principle will be implemented.
Conclusions
The Constitutional Court puts an end to an unjustified disparity between domestic VAT and import VAT, but the road to a fully consistent customs system that respects constitutional principles still appears to be a long one.